Reasons for Choosing to Buy a Dog Instead of Adopt

Dog Pet Buying vs Adoption

In recent years people who choose to buy a dog from a breeder have become the target of those who advocate adopting a dog from a shelter.

But this isn’t fair because technically, a person who buys a dog from a breeder is also adopting that pet.

They just choose to buy a specific breed instead of waiting for the perfect dog to be surrendered to a shelter.

And, if you buy a dog through a reputable site like, there is nothing wrong with this approach toward dog ownership. Here’s why.

Which is better in buying a dog or adoption

Dog History

When you adopt a dog from a shelter, you don’t have control over that animal’s history.

They may have experienced horrible things from their previous owner that have made the dog anxious, shy, or even mean.

Those behaviors can take a long time for a dog to unlearn, even if you’re diligent about training the dog.

If you have children in the home, you may not even be able to adopt a shelter dog because you don’t know how they’re going to behave around young kids.

Many dogs from shelters come with the caveat that they can’t be adopted out to families with children or other pets.

With a breeder, you’ll know everything you need to know about the puppy’s history and that of its parents.

Reputable breeders keep meticulous records about their dog’s ancestors and will be more than happy to share that information with you.

Also, you’ll be getting a puppy that has almost no experience with humans other than the breeder themselves.

This means they’ll be nearly a clean slate for you to train how you wish and that means you have an opportunity to raise them right.


Breed Specific Needs

Another major reason why people might choose to shop and not adopt is that they have breed-specific needs.

For instance, if you’re allergic to dogs that shed, you’ll need to get a dog that doesn’t shed or sheds very little.

These dogs can be very difficult to find in shelters and they are usually adopted very quickly when they are.

You may have to wait months, if not years before the right dog is surrendered to a shelter and even then, you might have to jump through a lot of hoops before you can take that dog home.

Other times when a specific breed is required for a pet owner include getting a specific dog as an emotional support animal or as an assistance dog.

Some breeds simply make better guide dogs or emotional support dogs than other breeds.

You don’t want a high-strung poodle, for instance, trying to help someone who suffers from severe anxiety.

German shepherds are well-known for their abilities to sense when their owner needs help, but they often need to be raised from a puppy to develop those skills.

Getting a shelter dog and turning them into a guide dog is not usually feasible.



If you choose to buy a dog instead of adopting one from a shelter, don’t feel ashamed.

Those dogs need homes too and you need to do what’s right for your family and life situation.

Just be sure to choose a reputable breeder with a track record of raising healthy puppies.